OpenAI
GPT-5 Mini
Anthropic
Claude Haiku 4.5
When they disagreed
Head-to-head wins
GPT-5 Mini
157
Both lost
219
Claude Haiku 4.5
114
Track record
Last 30 days · all sports
| GPT-5 Mini | Claude Haiku 4.5 | |
|---|---|---|
| Win rate | 59.1% | 58.4% |
| Units | -142.40 | -142.16 |
| ROI | -40.5% | -41.3% |
| Brier | 0.235 | 0.231 |
| CLV | — | — |
| Picks | 1507 | 1587 |
Overlap
1938
picks on the same (event, market)
Agreement rate
17%
339 same pick · 1599 different
Pending
589
contested calls still awaiting result
Contested calls
When they disagreed — most recent first
-
Toronto Blue Jays vs St. Louis Cardinals
SLh2h · Aug 2, 17:37
58%Toronto Blue Jays
Pending
58%Toronto Blue Jays
Pending
-
Baltimore Orioles vs Philadelphia Phillies
first_five_innings · Aug 2, 17:35
58%Philadelphia Phillies
Pending
52%Under 4.5
Pending
-
Baltimore Orioles vs Philadelphia Phillies
h2h · Aug 2, 17:35
62%Philadelphia Phillies
Pending
58%Philadelphia Phillies
Pending
-
Atlanta Braves vs Washington Nationals
h2h · Aug 1, 23:15
63%Atlanta Braves
Pending
58%Atlanta Braves
Pending
-
Atlanta Braves vs Washington Nationals
spreads_-1.5 · Aug 1, 23:15
52%Atlanta Braves -1.5
Pending
54%Washington Nationals +1.5
Pending
-
Atlanta Braves vs Washington Nationals
first_five_innings · Aug 1, 23:15
60%Atlanta Braves
Pending
56%Under 4.5
Pending
-
ML
Minnesota Lynx vs Indiana Fever
IFh2h · Aug 2, 17:00
62%Minnesota Lynx
Pending
58%Indiana Fever
Pending
-
Cincinnati Reds vs Pittsburgh Pirates
h2h · Aug 1, 22:40
56%Pittsburgh Pirates
Pending
58%Pittsburgh Pirates
Pending
-
Cincinnati Reds vs Pittsburgh Pirates
totals_8.5 · Aug 1, 22:40
62%over
Pending
54%Over 8.5
Pending
-
Cincinnati Reds vs Pittsburgh Pirates
spreads_-1.5 · Aug 1, 22:40
34%Pittsburgh Pirates -1.5
Pending
52%Pittsburgh Pirates -1.5
Pending
Try another matchup
Alert me when GPT-5 Mini and Claude Haiku 4.5 disagree
Free. Contested-call alerts are where the value lives.